Everyone is a genius. But if you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing that it is stupid.
Credited to Albert Einstein in a 2004 self help book, fans of a good social media quote will have undoubtedly become familiar with the idea via one of it's many adaptations into memes, videos or articles.
It's attack on the education system is valid and poignant. The idea that since Victorian times the education system has become a 'one-size-fits-all' process of forcing children to adhere to the same set of rigid standards, made all the more perverse in it's obsession with concrete testing is a genuine concern for everyone. The quote perpetuates the idea that in an ideal world, education doesn't look like it does today. In an ideal world, no-one is made to feel like a failure, because they aren't tested on something that may be their weakness. Rather, they are judged on their individual strengths, which are fostered and nurtured into 'genius' rather than disregarded in the instance that they do not conform to a politicians narrow view of what constitutes success in the school system.
So what happens if we remove a 'one-size-fits-all' system? Surely right here you have your argument for grammar schools. Why shouldn't we openly acknowledge that some children are just naturally more gifted when it comes to academia, and therefore should quite rightly be creamed off and left to flourish, away from the constant frustration of having their pace of learning interrupted by those whose skills lie elsewhere?
Why don't we recognise the child who is gifted at art and tailor an education around that, perhaps we could even separate and group them together?
The personable characters, the comedians, the salesmen, could they be grouped?
The child who is gifted with their hands, why waste time teaching them cumbersome volumes of maths and English, when we can just nourish those skills?
What do we do when we get to the child who has special educational needs?
To answer these questions, let's not forget that actually the one-size-fits-all system already does get dismantled to a large degree at the age of 16, when our young adults are perceived to be ready to make those decisions about who they are. Aside from providing a broader commentary on the standards imposed by society in general, let's therefore assume that we are looking at education prior to 16 when we explore Einsteins quote. Here is where it becomes problematic. If you start to separate children out prior to this, then how do you maintain equal opportunities?
In order to give every child the same chance to succeed, you need to provide them with the same opportunities. That's the entire thinking behind having a national curriculum, something that ensures that a uniform approach is taken to teaching so that a child in school A is just as likely to succeed as a child in school B.
For me the problem is not that we have a National Curriculum, it's that the one we have just isn't very good. I said earlier that in an ideal world some children wouldn't be made to feel like failures because they are constantly tested on their weaknesses rather than strengths. I'd conclude by saying that actually in an ideal education system, EVERY child would know what it felt like to experience a degree of failure/inferiority and EVERY child would know what it felt like to experience a degree of success/superiority because the curriculum was diverse enough and weighted fairly enough to facilitate that. Failing is one of the most important parts of learning. When we look at the children who are successful in today's standardised testing, we need to remember that by denying them a chance to get outside their comfort zone and, heaven forbid, actually experience some degree of failure, we've actually done them a dis-service too.
Here's the thing with the quote. We don't know off the bat which children are fish, and which are monkey's or whatever, and if we start trying to categorise children too early on, we risk creating a system which is grossly unfair. You find out who you are and what you're good at by getting out there and trying it all and experiencing it all. What education needs to do is revise, diversify and radically overhaul the national curriculum in such a way that all children are given equal opportunities to try, to fail, to learn and to succeed. Then we could have a generation of 16 year old's who were totally comfortable and confident in who they are and where their skills lie, and ready to make those important choices about what they'd like to pursue next. Until that point, education should be open, inclusive, diverse, practical, driven by 'real world' experience, open to the value of failure, interesting, mind expanding, thought provoking, awe inspiring and absolutely nothing like the archaic document Gove produced in one of the largest steps backwards since Blunkett forced us to over saturate the day with 'core' subjects and scrap the statutory framework for foundation subjects.
I totally appreciate how this new curriculum has inspired people to share Einstein's quote, but let's not allow an overly simple idea blind us to the fact that creating an education system that provides equal opportunities whilst simultaneously acknowledging we are all different is a complex achievement, and one that will never be reached if we mistakenly try to remove failure from the equation rather than embracing it as something that is, ironically, the only viable route to success. The fish may well believe he is stupid when he can't climb the tree, but when we allow him to swim as well, in the end he is richer and more self aware for the experience, just as the monkey is when he sees the fish he laughed at in the tree race past him in the bowl. Perhaps the motivation of the fish to climb the tree will lead to a great invention, likewise the monkey's motivation to swim in the bowl. Providing children with simultaneous opportunities to both flourish and flounder is what develops problem solving, robustness and character.
Our education system doesn't need to test and treat all of the children differently, it just needs to provide genuinely equal opportunities to everyone.
Sadly, this is something which the current National Curriculum sorely fails to deliver.