With December just days away and the Christmas play script decided upon, for a little school in the backstreets of Hounslow the festive season has officially arrived. If the stress of spending the next few weeks listening to children whom for the most part have no idea who Jesus is singing about the miracle of a virgin's birth (undoubtedly out of time with both the CD and each other) does not kill us, then alas the looming threat of an overdue Ofsted inspection slap bang in the middle of Mary and Josephs moment of glory in the spotlight certainly is.
The problem with Ofsted's latest set of 'bright ideas' to raise standards in education, aside from the obvious consensus amongst teachers that they seem to have been formulated with an extremely generous disregard for common sense, is that Ofsted places far too much emphasis on judging individual lessons using criteria which expose a large degree of ignorance when it comes to understanding the way education actually works.
Take Eastenders, if you will. We all know the Christmas special will be firing on all cylinders. Someone will get murdered. Something will blow up. They'll definitely be tears. All those things you need on Christmas day to reassure you that something, somehow, could be worse than sitting in a paper hat with a stomach ache, cradling some hot wine with bits of cinnamon floating about in the top. However, Eastender's could not deliver the Christmas special every day of the week, because in order to get to the special, we need build up. We need episodes that explain and explore who the characters are. Sometimes, we just need generic episodes to keep us going, to remind us what's going on even if they only add a little something to the story.
And so it goes with lessons. Sometimes, we will have the 'Christmas Special'. We'll fire on all cylinders, the input will go down a storm, at the tables every child will achieve and progress (we'll even laminate some resources for it). But lessons are episodes, and not every one can be the 'Christmas special'. Sometimes, one group of children will be consolidating a skill, building their independence and practicing success while another group can move on with the teacher. Sometimes, we want to lay the foundation for future work, so we'll give children an experience at the risk of having the lesson attacked because it didn't demonstrate every child making rapid and sustained progress all the way through.
We all know that children do not make progress in a diagonal linear lines. Most children make progress in short, rapid bursts, and those bursts occur more frequently when they are happy, engaged, motivated and secure. They are not best bought about by a teacher eagerly pushing children to capacity with as much literacy and numeracy as is humanly possible to cram into each and every morning in a desperate bid to make their spreadsheets more appealing. We do our children a disservice when we are forced to teach in this way. We shy away from delivering an enriching and invigorating curriculum as we slowly become obsessed with the notion that we need to prove every scrap of progress a child makes to validate our teaching.
We all know that children do not make progress in a diagonal linear lines. Most children make progress in short, rapid bursts, and those bursts occur more frequently when they are happy, engaged, motivated and secure. They are not best bought about by a teacher eagerly pushing children to capacity with as much literacy and numeracy as is humanly possible to cram into each and every morning in a desperate bid to make their spreadsheets more appealing. We do our children a disservice when we are forced to teach in this way. We shy away from delivering an enriching and invigorating curriculum as we slowly become obsessed with the notion that we need to prove every scrap of progress a child makes to validate our teaching.
All of this comes before even mentioning that Ofsted will want me to demonstrate, in this twenty minute 'Christmas Special' how I am catering for the children in my class that they have decided should be my priority. "And how are you supporting your free school meals? And how are you challenging your more able and your gifted and talented pupils? And where do your S.E.N children sit? And how much progress have they made? And why is that child with learning difficulties not making progress at exactly the same rate as that child who does not?" (Perhaps I should refer to it as the Ofsted 'Christmas Miracle' if I manage to answer that one in the absence of sarcasm and exasperation).
The answers should really be; I'll tell you the name of every child in my class, and where every child sits, because no one child in my class is more or less important to me in any way depending on your priorities. I refuse to share my time unfairly or dedicate extra to a particular group to suit your fad. Every child in my class enjoys coming to school. Every child in my class is making tremendous progress. Some of this can be seen by admiring the pretty colours on my pupil asset spreadsheets. Some of this can't be seen there, but if you have a little chat with the kid who came to me without English and sat under the table for a month, you might see how the fact he can now converse in English and begin to engage in lessons is one of the many little battles we win every day which your organisation fails to recognize.
Alas I fear like everyone else I'll opt to jump through the hoops when they arrive. I'll attempt to put on the Christmas Special and blag my way through as much of their tediousness as I can bear. But at least I can add my voice here to the thousands strong list of disgruntled teachers who think Ofsted should stand for:
Outrageously Futile System Trashing Education Daily
Or for the less polite version, give this video a whirl...
Merry Christmas, anecdotes and comments welcome and warmly received :)
No comments:
Post a Comment